What’s more important when hiring caregivers … attitude or skill?

Stephen Tweed | October 16, 2012 | Newsroom
By Diane West Program Manager Caregiver Quality Assurance (TM) After years of talking with home care owners about high turnover it’s become clear that selecting caregivers with a great attitude is more important than selecting based on skill.  This type of thinking, however, will require a change of mind-set for many home care companies. Yes,…

By Diane West
Program Manager
Caregiver Quality Assurance (TM)

After years of talking with home care owners about high turnover it’s become clear that selecting caregivers with a great attitude is more important than selecting based on skill.  This type of thinking, however, will require a change of mind-set for many home care companies.
Yes, it’s important, sometimes required, for a caregiver to have certain skills and/or certifications.  However, if someone has the right attitude you can teach them the skills necessary to do their job.  Look at your best caregivers. What is the common thread?  Yep, that’s what we thought … they have a can-do attitude.  You know you can count on them to fill in on short notice, stay late if necessary and they have a passion for their work.  Clients notice this too!
Many companies look for assessment results with the ‘right number’ to signify an applicant will be dependable.  The norm has also been to require applicants to have previous caregiving experience, which hasn’t proven to be a good indicator of a successful caregiver.  Carol Quinn, CEO of Hire Authority, says it best … “High achievers have three characteristics:  Attitude, Passion, and Skill.”  These are the three characteristics that every home care company is looking for … and they should be in this order.
Now, the dilemma … how do you determine a person’s attitude? Leading Home Care can help with our Caregiver Quality Assurance® program.  We offer a reasonably priced annual license for an online screening and selection process comprised of four assessments and an on-boarding tool.  Now you can determine early in your screening process a candidate’s attitudes by measuring for counter-productive behaviors.  You can streamline your interview process with behavioral interview questions specific to the candidate’s responses.
Benefits of being a member of Caregtiver Quality Assurance (TM)
  • Unlimited assessment usage for one year
  • Choose which of four assessments applicants will complete (Job Fit, Cognitive, Attitude, Engagement)
  • Assessments are benchmarked to the job
  • Review results immediately
  • On-boarding tool available to help you understand a candidates personality characteristics and learning style, before you hire them

  • Applicants can take the assessment in your office or remotely, your choice
  • Display the CQA seal to showcase your dedication to quality care

Your caregivers are the face of your company.  They reflect your values when providing care.  A caregiver with a bad attitude can negatively impact your business in a variety of ways.  Let us help you find applicants with the right attitude to become successful caregivers.   

Contact Diane West at 502-339-0653 or diane@leadinghomecare.com to learn more about the assessments or go to www.caregiverquality.com and request a free demo.
Stephen Tweed
Stephen Tweed is among the top Thought Leaders in Home Care today. As an industry researcher, author, and executive coach, he has worked with owners and CEOs of companies in the top 5% of Home Care and is a frequent speaker at Home Care association conferences and corporate meetings across the US and Canada.

Related Posts

The Top Five Applications of AI in Home Care

March 12, 2026
We recently surveyed over 320 Home Care agency Founders, Owners, and CEOs as part of the 2026 Future of Home Care Study, conducted by Leading Home Carean published by AxisCare. From last year's survey we found that many Home Care leaders are looking at the possibilities for AI in their businesses, so this year we dug more deeply into…

All That Jazz

March 5, 2026
Last night we attended a terrific jazz concert at Artis-Naples, the museum and performance venue here in Naples Florida. My wife, Elizabeth Jeffries, and I really enjoy the music here. Last night's performance featured Gary Smulyan, Grammy winning Baritone Saxophonist leading a six-piece ensemble. As the band moved through their set, Elizabeth leaned over and whispered, "Look at their faces.…

Finding and Keeping Caregivers

February 26, 2026
In January, we published the 2026 Future of Home Care Study, conducted by Leading Home Care ... a Tweed Jeffries company, and sponsored by AxisCare. This is the third year for this industry-leading research, and we captured some very interesting new data and information. However, one thing is not new. The biggest pain points for Home Care CEOs for…