Case Study: Limit Your Liability with Caregiver Training

Stephen Tweed | October 14, 2015 | News and Views
By David Dickie CEO, The Solutions Group What's your potential liability if a client is injured and your caregiver has not been properly trained? This matter involves 96-year-old client Steven Smith (all names changed) who suffered severe injuries to the face and forehead resulting in death on July 31, 20XX when he was ejected from his…

By David DickieWheelchair Crash

CEO, The Solutions Group

What’s your potential liability if a client is injured and your caregiver has not been properly trained?

This matter involves 96-year-old client Steven Smith (all names changed) who suffered severe injuries to the face and forehead resulting in death on July 31, 20XX when he was ejected from his wheelchair on a wheelchair ramp outside his home. The caregiver that day, Janice Thomas, was a replacement for the normal caregiver, who had called in sick. Notably, there was no documentation of training of the replacement caregiver regarding wheelchair use. On January 22nd, 20XX the insured received a letter from Weis, Petersen, Bowles & Skinner stating that the accident was a proximate result of negligence by Ms. Thomas, specifically that the wheelchair was wheeled frontwards down the ramp, rather than backwards as is normal procedure and that Mr. Smith was not strapped into the wheelchair.

ABC Home Health Care turned the letter over to their liability carrier. The carrier made an affirmative coverage determination and initiated an investigation.

The caregiver denied wheeling the client forward down the ramp. The insurance company came to the conclusion that the facts of the case portrayed a different set of events, specifically that it would be almost impossible to pitch forcibly out of a wheelchair, and have damage to the forehead and face, if the wheelchair were in fact going backward down a ramp. And even if backwards, not strapping into the chair, as was normal documented procedure for this client and stated in the plan of care, was negligence enough.

Liability to the caregiver and agency seemed clear.

The insurance company immediately commenced settlement negotiations. Surprisingly, the attorney for the estate of Steven Smith demanded only $150,000 in damages. Negotiations ensued, with a final settlement of $100,000 and defense costs of $12,025. It could have been much worse.

Prevention:

Train replacement caregivers and document the training

Wheelchair use training for all caregivers

Liability Insurance Research Report

Liability Insurance - cover image for website

To help you get a better understanding of your potential liability as the owner of a home care company, and to help  you understand the principles of insurance for business owners, Leading Home Care has conducted a study of the principles of liability and workers compensation insurance.  We have written a special research report, and this report is available to you without cost compliments of The Solutions Group.  Download your free copy of this valuable report today.

Free download

Stephen Tweed
Stephen Tweed is among the top Thought Leaders in Home Care today. As an industry researcher, author, and executive coach, he has worked with owners and CEOs of companies in the top 5% of Home Care and is a frequent speaker at Home Care association conferences and corporate meetings across the US and Canada.

Related Posts

Shared Vision Can Change Your Life

August 21, 2025
This past week, I was in Fort Myers, FL leading an Executive Strategy Retreat for a wonderful family-owned Home Care company. We spent a full day using the storyboarding technique from the Walt Disney organization to stimulate creativity, make ideas visible, and craft a five-year vision for the company. We then dug into detail as we defined…

Corporate Culture in Home Care

August 7, 2025
I've been thinking a lot about Corporate Culture in Home Care For the past few weeks, I've been deeply immersed in the final preparation for the start of school. As you may have heard, I recently accepted a position as Adjunct Instructor of Corporate Culture in the Master of Arts in Communication and Business Leadership at High Point…

Appreciation and Recognition

July 31, 2025
This past Tuesday evening I was in Scottsdale, AZ for the annual CPAE Speaker Hall of Fame Awards, and the Cavett Award, presented by the National Speakers Association. This is the final formal banquet that brings to a grand finale the annual convention of NSA. The National Speakers Association is a society of experts who speak professionally. These are some of…