What the Data Say about the Caregiver Recruiting and Retention Crisis

Stephen Tweed | May 24, 2017 | News and Views, Research & Trends
By Stephen Tweed If you have been reading the Home Care CEO Report for any length of time, you know that I am a huge fan of Aaron Marcum and the annual Home Care Benchmarking Study from Home Care Pulse.  I carry my copy with me every where I go so that I can access the…
Order Your Copy Today

By Stephen Tweed

If you have been reading the Home Care CEO Report for any length of time, you know that I am a huge fan of Aaron Marcum and the annual Home Care Benchmarking Study from Home Care Pulse.  I carry my copy with me every where I go so that I can access the latest facts and data about the private pay in-home care industry.

This year, I waited patiently for the latest facts and data about the Caregiver Recruiting and Retention Crisis in home care.  My copy arrived a couple of weeks ago as I was on my way out the door for a speaking engagement in California. That gave me a long plane ride to read the report and study the data.

What the Data Say

I spent a lot of time going over the data in the Caregiver Recruitment and Retention section of the report to see if there were any new insights that would help us in conquering the crisis.  This year’s report reinforced some data points that we’ve seen for the past four our five years:

  • The number one factor that sets a provider apart from other agencies is Caregiver Quality
  • The biggest threat facing home care providers is Caregiver Shortages
  • Turnover went up again this year to 65.7%
  • The best sources of caregivers is the internet – Indeed.com and Craigslist
  • The best non-internet source of caregivers is employee referrals
  • Median caregiver acquisition costs ranged from $216.17 to $512.52
Some New Insights

In reviewing the data, I found a couple of key insights that may help you find and keep higher quality caregivers.

  • The recruitment sources with the highest turnover are the internet; specifically Indeed.com, Craigslist, and myCNAjobs.com.
  • The recruitment source with the lowest acquisition cost had the highest turnover rate – myCNAjobs.com
  • The recruitment sources with the lowest turnover rate had the highest acquisition cost – Referral Sources and Employee Referrals
The Data Reinforce our Recommendation

In my forthcoming book, Conquering the Crisis: Proven Solutions for Caregiver Recruiting and Retention, I propose a three-pronged strategy for caregiver recruiting:

  1. Employee Referrals
  2. Digital Recruiting
  3. Face to Face Recruiting

In the chapter on Attract the Best, I give you the results of our 2015 Caregiver Recruiting Study, and show how you can implement this three-pronged approach.  While the study is two years old, this year’s Home Care Benchmarking Study shows that the data from our study is still relevant, reliable, and valid.

Conquering the Crisis will be published on June 1, 2017 by Red Letter Press in Austin, TX.  You can pre-order a copy today, and save 40% off the cover price.

 

Stephen Tweed
Stephen Tweed is among the top Thought Leaders in Home Care today. As an industry researcher, author, and executive coach, he has worked with owners and CEOs of companies in the top 5% of Home Care and is a frequent speaker at Home Care association conferences and corporate meetings across the US and Canada.

Related Posts

Shared Vision Can Change Your Life

August 21, 2025
This past week, I was in Fort Myers, FL leading an Executive Strategy Retreat for a wonderful family-owned Home Care company. We spent a full day using the storyboarding technique from the Walt Disney organization to stimulate creativity, make ideas visible, and craft a five-year vision for the company. We then dug into detail as we defined…

Corporate Culture in Home Care

August 7, 2025
I've been thinking a lot about Corporate Culture in Home Care For the past few weeks, I've been deeply immersed in the final preparation for the start of school. As you may have heard, I recently accepted a position as Adjunct Instructor of Corporate Culture in the Master of Arts in Communication and Business Leadership at High Point…

Appreciation and Recognition

July 31, 2025
This past Tuesday evening I was in Scottsdale, AZ for the annual CPAE Speaker Hall of Fame Awards, and the Cavett Award, presented by the National Speakers Association. This is the final formal banquet that brings to a grand finale the annual convention of NSA. The National Speakers Association is a society of experts who speak professionally. These are some of…