New Study Affirms Effectiveness of Home and Community Based Services

Stephen Tweed | December 16, 2013 | News and Views
The University of Minnesota’s National Residential Information Systems Project (RISP) recently released a study titled Residential Services for Persons with Intellectual or Developmental Disabilities: Status and Trends Through 2011 (the Study).  The Study’s major findings as they apply to home and community-based services (HCBS) and rebalancing are below. HCBS Waivers: The number of people with…

The University of Minnesota’s National Residential Information Systems Project (RISP) recently released a study titled Residential Services for Persons with Intellectual or Developmental Disabilities: Status and Trends Through 2011 (the Study)The Study’s major findings as they apply to home and community-based services (HCBS) and rebalancing are below.

HCBS Waivers: The number of people with intellectual and developmental disabilities (IDD) that are recipients of HCBS waivers increased dramatically, from 1,381 in 1982, to 62,429 in 1992, to 373,946 in 2002, and to 616,491 in 2011.  Total IDD HCBS waiver expenditures increased from $10.9 billion in 2001 to $26.3 billion in 2010 to $27.9 billion in 2011. From 2001 to 2011, the degree of expenditure increase varied significantly across states, with Illinois, Mississippi, New York and Ohio experiencing increases above 500%, while California, Michigan, New Hampshire, Oklahoma, and Rhode Island seeing increases from 25% to 73%.  HCBS waiver recipients accounted for 69.0% of the national IDD population in 2010.

Rebalancing: The Study provided several statistics demonstrating the success of rebalancing of the IDD population.  The average daily population living in either psychiatric or large state-operated IDD facilities decreased from 187,305 nationally in 1965 to 103,629 in 1985 and to 29,809 in 2011.  Relative to the general population, the institutionalized IDD population declined as well.   The proportion of those with IDD living in either psychiatric or large state-operated IDD facilities as compared to the general population fell from 115.8 per 100,000 nationally in 1965 to 49.3 per 100,000 in 1985 and to 9.6 per 100,000 in 2011.

Further evidence of rebalancing is demonstrated when comparing the proportion of IDD population residing in Intermediate Care Facility for Individuals with Intellectual Disabilities (ICF-IDs) (27.2 out of 100,000) versus those receiving HCBS (197.9 out of 100,000) in 2011.  The utilization levels of HCBS relative to the population varied significantly among states.  Eight states had over 350 out of 100,000 receiving HCBS (Arizona, Iowa, Minnesota, New York, North Dakota, South Dakota, Vermont, and Wyoming), while five state had fewer than 100 per 100,000 receiving HCBS (Delaware, Michigan, Mississippi, Nevada, and Texas).

Cost-Effectiveness of Rebalancing: The Study confirmed the cost-effectiveness of HCBS compared to institutional care.  In 2011, annual Medicaid expenditures per person in ICF-IDs was $148,146, versus only $45,294 per person for IDD HCBS.

For the full Study click here.

Stephen Tweed
Stephen Tweed is among the top Thought Leaders in Home Care today. As an industry researcher, author, and executive coach, he has worked with owners and CEOs of companies in the top 5% of Home Care and is a frequent speaker at Home Care association conferences and corporate meetings across the US and Canada.

Related Posts

Shared Vision Can Change Your Life

August 21, 2025
This past week, I was in Fort Myers, FL leading an Executive Strategy Retreat for a wonderful family-owned Home Care company. We spent a full day using the storyboarding technique from the Walt Disney organization to stimulate creativity, make ideas visible, and craft a five-year vision for the company. We then dug into detail as we defined…

Corporate Culture in Home Care

August 7, 2025
I've been thinking a lot about Corporate Culture in Home Care For the past few weeks, I've been deeply immersed in the final preparation for the start of school. As you may have heard, I recently accepted a position as Adjunct Instructor of Corporate Culture in the Master of Arts in Communication and Business Leadership at High Point…

Appreciation and Recognition

July 31, 2025
This past Tuesday evening I was in Scottsdale, AZ for the annual CPAE Speaker Hall of Fame Awards, and the Cavett Award, presented by the National Speakers Association. This is the final formal banquet that brings to a grand finale the annual convention of NSA. The National Speakers Association is a society of experts who speak professionally. These are some of…